Home › Denial Codes › CO-23

CO-23 Denial Code: Impact of Prior Payer Adjudication (Secondary Claims)

What CO-23 means on your remittance, exactly how to fix it, and the appeal language that gets it overturned.

Advertisement

Free appeal letter tool. Build a complete appeal for this denial with the free appeal letter generator — it fills in the payer, dates and claim details for you.

What Does CO-23 Mean?

Code 23 — usually seen as OA-23 — is the least understood code on secondary remittances, because it isn't a denial at all. It reports the impact of the primary payer's adjudication: the amount the primary already paid or adjusted, which the secondary is subtracting before calculating its own payment. Seeing 23 on a secondary EOB is normal arithmetic, not a problem.

Code group: OA/CO (informational adjustment)  ·  Appealable: Only when the prior-payer amounts used were wrong. Otherwise it's normal secondary-claim math — post it correctly.

Why CO-23 Happens

  • You billed a secondary payer after the primary paid, and the secondary is showing the primary's payment and contractual adjustments as an offset — exactly as coordination of benefits is supposed to work.
  • The secondary paid less than expected, and the 23 amount explains why: primary payment plus adjustments consumed most of the allowed amount.
  • Medigap and crossover claims display 23 routinely as the Medicare payment flows through.
  • The one real problem case: the 23 amount doesn't match what the primary actually paid — a data mismatch between the claim you submitted and the primary EOB.
Advertisement

How to Fix a CO-23 Denial — Step by Step

1
First: confirm nothing is actually wrong. Compare the 23 amount against the primary's EOB. If they match, the remittance is simply showing correct COB math — post it and move on.
2
If the secondary paid $0, check whether that's correct: when the primary's payment meets or exceeds the secondary's allowed amount, zero is the right answer, not a denial to fight.
3
If the 23 amount doesn't match the primary EOB, the secondary adjudicated against wrong prior-payer data — resubmit with the correct primary EOB attached or correct the COB fields on the claim.
4
Verify the remaining patient responsibility: after both payers, PR amounts on the secondary remittance are what the patient owes — often nothing.
5
Train posters on code 23 specifically; mis-posting it as a denial creates phantom AR and wasted follow-up calls.

What To Do With CO-23 (Hint: Usually Nothing)

Adapt this wording to your claim — replace the bracketed fields and attach the documentation it references:

There's nothing to appeal in a correct CO-23/OA-23 — it's arithmetic. When the numbers are wrong: 'Secondary claim [number] was adjudicated using prior-payer payment data of [$X]; the primary payer's remittance (attached) shows actual payment of [$Y] and contractual adjustment of [$Z]. We request reprocessing with the corrected prior-payer amounts.'

How to Prevent CO-23

  • Submit secondary claims with complete, accurate primary EOB data — mismatches cause the only real 23 problems.
  • Teach payment posters what 23 means so it never gets worked as a denial.
  • Reconcile secondary payments against the COB math for your top payer pairs monthly.

Related Denial Codes

← Back to the full denial code library

Reviewed by the LegitMedBilling denial management team. This guide is general billing information, not legal or payer-specific advice — always verify against your payer contract and current policy.

Advertisement

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CO-23 a denial?
No — and that's the whole point. It reports how much the primary payer's payment and adjustments reduced what the secondary considers. It's coordination-of-benefits arithmetic on the remittance. The only time it needs action is when the amounts don't match the primary's actual EOB.
The secondary paid $0 and showed code 23. Did we lose money?
Usually not. If the primary's payment met or exceeded the secondary's allowed amount for the service, the secondary correctly owes nothing — the code 23 line shows the math. Compare allowed amounts before assuming a problem; zero-pay secondaries are often correct.
Why does our AR show a pile of 'CO-23 denials' to work?
Because someone posted informational adjustments as denials — one of the most common posting errors in billing. Those aren't workable claims; they're arithmetic lines. Clean them up, then fix the posting rule so code 23 posts as an adjustment reference, not a denial queue item.
Advertisement

Hassan Raza AwanReviewed by Hassan Raza Awan, Founder — 4+ years of hands-on U.S. medical billing experience. General billing information — verify against current CMS guidance and your payer contracts.

Free tool: Secondary Payer Calculator — check whether the prior payer’s adjudication left anything the secondary actually owes. Planning an appeal? Our TFL and AFL calculator shows the last day to send it.

Tired of Fighting Denials Yourself?

Our denial management team recovers revenue for practices nationwide. Get a free one-week denial audit.

Get Free Denial Audit Denial Management Services